Doe and I were not exclusive when I met Jay. That’s the part I need you to understand first.

Jay and I were just talking. You know how it is when you meet someone new and there’s that spark, that curiosity. We were getting to know each other, nothing serious yet. Then one day he just put it out there. He said, “I like you.” And I thought about it, and I figured why not give him a try. So I did.

A few weeks later, somehow Jay found out about Doe. The person I was already seeing. When Jay found out, he asked me to choose between them. I refused. It wasn’t that I was being difficult. I genuinely liked both of them. They each brought something different into my life. Doe understood parts of me that Jay couldn’t reach. Jay made me feel things that Doe didn’t. I wasn’t ready to lose either one.

But a few days after that conversation, I broke things off with Jay anyway. It just felt like the right thing to do. He needed to go his way and I needed to go mine. He ended up getting married a few months later.

When he traveled abroad and started having minor issues in his marriage, I was there. He would call me frustrated, exhausted, questioning everything. And I would sit on the phone and tell him, “Calm down. Be patient. Marriage is hard. You made a vow.” Sometimes I would take a break from being his counselor because it drained me emotionally. But I always came back. I thought I was being a good person. A good friend. Looking back, I wonder if I was just fooling myself.

FOLLOW US ON WHATSAPP CHANNEL TO RECEIVE ALL STORIES IN YOUR INBOX

Last year, Jay decided to try again. He came back to me as a divorced man. This time I said yes. Things moved fast. We did an informal introduction to both our parents. My mother liked him. His father shook my hand and said I seemed like a decent girl. It felt serious. It felt right. I let myself believe this was it. Like the universe had finally worked out the timing for us.

But then something changed in Jay. He started accusing me of cheating. At first I downplayed it. I told myself it was just the long distance talking. The insecurity that comes with not being able to see your person every day. But the attitude kept escalating. He would go days without speaking to me. Complete radio silence. And I would sit there staring at my phone, wondering what I did wrong. If I missed his call even once, it became a whole thing. He would ask me where I was, who I was with, why I didn’t pick up. Hours of questioning. It put so much strain on us.

Every time we had a misunderstanding, he would bring up the cheating accusations. No proof. No evidence. Just suspicion eating away at whatever we were trying to build. I finally asked him straight up why he kept doing this. Why he kept accusing me. And he said something that stopped me cold.

He said I cheated on him in the past. That if I could do it while he was in the country, I could do it again now that he’s not around.

In the end, Jay broke up with me. I didn’t see it coming. One day he was here, the next day he was gone. And that’s what makes this so confusing. Apart from this one thing, this constant suspicion, he is genuinely a good person. Kind. Thoughtful. The kind of man you could build a life with. But he couldn’t let go of something that happened years ago. Something I thought we had moved past long before we ever got serious.

Now I’m left here second guessing everything. Was I wrong to talk to two people at once back then? Was I wrong to stay friends with him while he was married? Was I wrong to think we could start fresh?

So here is my question to you, especially the men reading this. I need to know. Was what I did back then actually cheating?

When Jay first approached me years ago, I told him I was seeing someone. I was honest about that from the beginning. We were not exclusive, me and Doe. Jay knew this and still pursued me. We dated briefly and I ended it. That was it. There was no sneaking around. No lies. No betrayal.

Was that cheating? And even if it was, does it justify him accusing me now, years later, with no evidence, no proof, nothing but suspicion?

What Will Make You Leave Me After Forty Years Of Marriage?

I’m not saying I’m perfect. I have my flaws. I stayed friends with someone who had feelings for me. I played counselor to a married man. Maybe that was messy. Maybe that was naive. But I can say this with complete honesty. I have not cheated on Jay during this relationship. Not once. Not emotionally. Not physically. Nothing.

I need to understand. Please help me understand.

—Maurie

This story you just read was sent to us by someone just like you. We know you have a story too. Email it to us at [email protected]. You can also drop your number and we will call you so you tell us your story.

 

#SB<>